Wage determination in competitive and non-competitive markets

Written by: Umar Bostan
Updated on30 October 2026
Wage Determination in Labour Markets
Labour Market Equilibrium
Labour market equilibrium occurs where the demand for labour (DL) is equal to the supply of labour (SL) giving quantity Qe and wage We .
Remember workers do the supplying of labour ,firms do the demanding (opposite to a goods market )
Current Labour Market Issues
Automation
Automation can reduce demand for labour where capital and labour are substitutes.
Technology ↑ → firms substitute capital for labour → demand for labour ↓ → employment ↓ → wages ↓
For example around 75,000 UK retail jobs were eliminated due to self checkout machines with over 50% of store transactions now passing through them .
However, capital and labour may also be complements.
Technology ↑ → demand for workers needed to develop, maintain and operate capital ↑ → demand for skilled labour ↑
For example, greater automation may increase demand for engineers and software developers.
Skills Shortages
A skills shortage occurs when firms struggle to find workers with the skills required for particular jobs.
Shortage of skilled labour → labour supply relatively low → firms compete for workers → wage rates ↑
For example a lack skilled engineers pushed average starting salaries up by over 7%, as firms outbid each other for limited talent.
Trade Unions and Strike Activity
A trade union is a group of workers that bargains collectively for higher wages and improved working conditions.
Trade unions can increase workers’ bargaining power.
Collective bargaining power ↑ → pressure on employers to raise wages or improve conditions ↑
Strike action → firms lose output and revenue → cost of continuing dispute ↑ → firms more likely to agree to wage demands
For example following 44 days of strike action that cost the NHS over £3 billion and delayed 1.5 million appointments, the BMA leveraged its collective bargaining power to secure a 22% pay rise for doctors.
Low Productivity Growth
Productivity affects labour demand because more productive workers generate more output and revenue for firms.
Productivity growth ↓ → MRP growth ↓ → growth in demand for labour ↓ → wage growth ↓
For example the UK has had the 2nd slowest productivity growth in the G7 since 2008 leading to real wage stagnation .
Youth Unemployment .
Young workers may experience higher unemployment because they often have less experience and skills .
Time outside employment or education ↑ → skills deteriorate + CV gaps ↑ → employability ↓ → structural unemployment ↑
For example Over 1 million 16 to 24 year olds are NEET (13.5%)
Minimum Wages
A minimum wage is a legal floor below which the hourly wage cannot fall.
For a minimum wage to affect the labour market, it must be set above the equilibrium wage.
Initially:
Equilibrium is reached where DL=SL thus giving us We wage rate and Qe quantity of labour .
The government introduces a minimum wage at W1, above We. This minimum wage forces the labour market into disequilibrum.
The higher wage incentivises workers to supply more labour thus shifting quantity supplied from Qe to Qs. On the other hand higher wages disincentives firms to hire workers as it is more costly thus demand decreases from Qe to Qd .
This therefore means the discrepancy (the gap ) between Qs and Qd represents excess supply of labour aka unemployment and specifically real wage unemployment .
For example National Minimum Wage in the UK in 2024 increased to £11.44/hr.
Benefits of a Minimum Wage
A minimum wage can increase the incomes of low paid workers thus reducing poverty and income inequality .
Higher wages may also improve worker motivation thus improving productivity
Higher wages can reduce labour turnover thus decreasing staff training costs for firms . For example UK Social care faces a around 30% annual turnover severely increasing staff training costs for firms.
Costs of a Minimum Wage
Higher wages increase firms labour costs thus likely to reduce demand for labour increasing unemployment .
Higher wage costs may also be passed onto consumers via higher prices .
Maximum Wages
A maximum wage is a ceiling above which wages cannot rise.
For it to affect the labour market, it must be set below the equilibrium wage.
Initially:
Equilibrium is reached where DL=SL thus giving us We wage rate and Qe quantity of labour.
The government introduces a maximum wage at Wmax, below We. This maximum wage forces the labour market into disequilibrium.
The lower wage disincentivises workers to supply labour thus shifting quantity supplied from Qe to Qs. On the other hand lower wages incentivise firms to hire workers as it is less costly thus demand increases from Qe to Qd.
This therefore means the discrepancy (the gap) between Qs and Qd represents excess demand for labour aka a labour shortage.
For example in 1961 the top flight of English football capped players pay at £20 per week.
For example UK bankers previously faced a cap limiting bonuses to 100% (or 200% with shareholder approval) of their base salary under EU rules .
Benefits of a Maximum Wage
Firms spend less on executive pay, more funds may be available for lower paid workers thus reducing income inequality .
Costs of a Maximum Wage
A maximum wage may reduce the incentive for highly skilled workers to supply their labour. As these workers often have the highest MRP, such as senior managers, shortages may reduce productivity and organisation. This can negatively affect lower paid workers, for example through fewer shifts or employment opportunities, potentially worsening income inequality.
Occupational and Geographical Immobility of Labour
Occupational Immobility
Occupational immobility of labour occurs when workers lack the skills or qualifications needed to change occupations thus increasing structural unemployment .
For example, Margaret Thatcher closed the mines down in 1984 . In the north of England there were several generations of families employed in working in the mines . The only skill they knew was coal mining .
Geographical Immobility
Geographical immobility of labour occurs when workers cannot easily move location to find work thus increasing structural unemployment .
For example, UK deindustrialisation caused manufacturing and mining jobs in Northern England to decline, while service sector jobs became increasingly concentrated in London. High housing costs made it difficult for some workers to relocate, increasing geographical immobility.
Policies to Reduce Labour Market Immobility
Improved Education and Training
Government spending on education and training can improve workers’ skills.
Training ↑ → skills ↑ → ability to move between occupations ↑ → occupational immobility ↓
For example UK govts tax funded software engineering bootcamps train former retail workers in coding .
Improving Transport Infrastructure
Government investment in trains and buses can improve geographical mobility.
Transport infrastructure ↑ → cost/time of commuting ↓ → workers can access more jobs → geographical immobility ↓
For example Scrapping the Leeds leg lost a 52 minute time saving per trip, keeping Yorkshire commuters locked out of rapid daily access to London's job market.
Housing and Relocation Support
The government could increase housing supply or provide relocation subsidies.
For example The UK government provides direct £10,000 relocation bursaries to attract and move foreign teachers to UK schools .
Public Sector Wage Setting
The government directly influences wages in areas such as:
Healthcare
Education
Police
Fire services
Independent pay review bodies make recommendations on wage rises, although the government decides whether to accept them.
Benefits of Increasing Public Sector Pay
Higher wages may attract additional workers.
Public sector wages ↑ → labour supply to public sector ↑ → staff shortages ↓
Higher pay may also reduce strike activity.
Pay ↑ → worker satisfaction ↑ → likelihood of strikes ↓ → disruption to public services ↓
Higher wages may also improve living standards and reduce poverty for affected workers.
Costs of Increasing Public Sector Pay
Higher public-sector wages increase government expenditure.
Public sector pay ↑ → government expenditure ↑ → budget deficit may ↑
The government may therefore need to:
Increase taxes or reduce spending elsewhere
This creates an opportunity cost, as additional spending on wages cannot be used for other government priorities.
Wage Elasticity of Demand for Labour
Wage elasticity of demand for labour (WED) measures the responsiveness of the quantity of labour demanded to a change in the wage rate.
Wage Elastic Demand for Labour
Despite only a small increase in wage from W1 to W2 it leads to a proportionally much larger decrease in quantity demanded of labour from Q2 to Q1
Firms are highly responsive to changes in wages.
Wage-Inelastic Demand for Labour
A large increase in wage from W1 to W2 leads to a proportionally much smaller decrease in quantity demanded of labour from Q2 to Q1
Firms are relatively unresponsive to changes in wages.
Wage Elasticity of Supply of Labour
Wage elasticity of supply of labour (WES) measures the responsiveness of the quantity of labour supplied to a change in the wage rate.
Wage-Elastic Supply of Labour
Despite only a small increase in wage from W1 to W2 it leads to a proportionally much larger increase in quantity supplied of labour from Q1 to Q2
This is more common in occupations with:
Low barriers to entry
Limited training requirements
Large pools of potential workers

Wage-Inelastic Supply of Labour
A large increase in wage from W1 to W2 leads to a proportionally much smaller increase in quantity supplied of labour from Q1 to Q2
This is more common in occupations requiring lengthy education and professional training.

Active recall
Revise with flashcards
Teacher Information

More Revision Notes you might like
Specification 3.5.3
Past paper questions on this topic
12 matched questions to practise alongside these notes.
- A-level Paper 1, June 2025, Q5(a) · 4 marks
Draw a labour market diagram to show the likely impact of the increase in the National Minimum Wage for hospitality employees.
- A-level Paper 3, June 2025, Q1(b) · 8 marks
With reference to Extract B, examine two likely reasons why wages in supermarkets are above the National Minimum Wage of £10.42.
- A-level Paper 3, June 2024, Q1(d) · 25 marks
Evaluate the microeconomic and macroeconomic factors that explain gender-based wage differences in the UK oil and gas industry.
- A-level Paper 1, June 2023, Q5(a) · 1 marks
Which one of the following is the ratio of public sector pay relative to private sector pay in 2022?
- A-level Paper 1, June 2023, Q5(b) · 4 marks
Over 90% of nurses work in the public sector. Nurses in the public sector have experienced wage rises lower than those in the private sector over the past 10 years. Using the information provided and the concept of monopsony, explain why nurses in the public sector have had lower wage rises than those in the private sector.
