Restrictions on free trade

Written by: Umar Bostan
Updated on30 October 2026
Restrictions on Free Trade
Restrictions on free trade are protectionist policies used by governments to limit international trade and protect the domestic economy. They include tariffs, quotas, subsidies and non-tariff barriers.
Free trade allows countries to specialise according to their comparative advantage, maximising global output. However, governments may restrict trade where they believe the costs of free trade outweigh these benefits.
Reasons for Restrictions on Free Trade
Protect Domestic Employment
Free trade increases competition from foreign firms. If domestic firms cannot compete with cheaper imports, they may reduce output or shut down, causing structural unemployment.
Foreign competition ↑ → demand for domestic goods ↓ → domestic output ↓ → derived demand for labour ↓ → unemployment ↑
Protectionism reduces foreign competition, helping to protect domestic firms and employment.
For example the US 50% tariff on imported steel preserved roughly 8,700 domestic steelmaking jobs,
Infant Industries
An infant industry is a new or developing industry which may initially struggle to compete against established foreign firms.
Temporary protection gives domestic firms time to expand and exploit economies of scale, lowering average costs and allowing them to become internationally competitive.
Protection from imports → domestic demand ↑ → output ↑ → economies of scale ↑ → average costs ↓ → international competitiveness ↑
Prevent Dumping
Dumping occurs when foreign firms sell goods at excessively low prices, potentially below their cost of production, to force competitors out of the market.
Dumping → import prices ↓ → demand for domestic goods ↓ → domestic firms lose market share → firms may exit
For example The US imposed anti-dumping duties of 52.5% on Samsung washing machines after finding they were sold below market value in America to undercut domestic manufacturers.
Reduce the Current Account Deficit
Protectionism can reduce expenditure on imports and therefore improve the trade balance and current account balance.
Tariffs/quotas → imports ↓ → import expenditure ↓ → net trade (X − M) ↑ → current account deficit ↓
Types of Restrictions on Free Trade
Tariffs
A tariff is a tax on imports.
A tariff increases the price of imported goods from Pw to Pw + T. As imports become more expensive, domestic consumer demand for imports falls from Q1-Q4 to Q2-Q3 . This means domestic consumers substitute away from buying goods from foreign producers to instead buying from domestic firms , keeping domestic firms demand high thus keeping derived demand for domestic labour high hence why we call these protectionist policies.
On a tariff diagram:
Domestic production increases (Q1 to Q2)
Imports decrease (Q1-Q4 to Q2-Q3)
Domestic producer surplus increases (A)
Consumer surplus decreases (Higher price due to lack of international competition)
Government receives tariff revenue ©
For example the US imposed a 50% tariff on foreign steel .
Quotas
A quota is a limit on the quantity of a good that can be imported.
Quota imposed → supply of cheaper imports restricted → shortage at original price → market price ↑ → domestic production ↑ + consumption ↓ → imports ↓
This protects domestic producers from foreign competition and may increase domestic employment. However, unlike a tariff, a standard quota provides no direct tariff revenue to the government.
For example Algeria imposed a strict import quota capping foreign vehicles at 83,000 units annually, causing domestic used car prices to surge by over 100%.
Also The US caps raw sugar imports at roughly 1.1 million tonnes, driving domestic US sugar prices to 2x the world market rate.
Subsidies to Domestic Producers
A subsidy is a payment from the government to domestic producers. It may be used to protect infant industries, which initially have high costs of production and struggle to compete with cheaper foreign producers.
Subsidy → effective costs of production ↓ → domestic supply shifts from S domestic to S domestic + subsidy → domestic firms become more competitive → domestic output increases from Q1 to Q3 → imports fall from Q4 − Q1 to Q4 − Q3 (thus acting as a protectionist policy)
Before the subsidy, domestic producers receive the world price Pw. After the subsidy, consumers continue to pay Pw, but domestic producers effectively receive Pw + subsidy per unit, with the difference funded by the government.
This allows higher cost domestic firms to increase production and compete with foreign producers without raising the price paid by consumers.
For example, the EU allocates €386.6 billion (around 32% of its budget) to subsidise European farmers, helping them compete against non-EU producers such as Brazilian beef and sugar exporters.(European Commission)
Non-Tariff Barriers
Non-tariff barriers are restrictions on trade that do not directly involve tariffs.
Examples include:
Health and safety regulations
Environmental regulations
Product labelling requirements
These increase the cost and difficulty of importing, reducing foreign competition.
For example, the EU’s health rules ban hormone treated beef imports, restricting US producers’ access to the EU market; the WTO valued the affected trade at $116 million per year. (WTO)
Impacts of Protectionism
Consumers
Protectionism generally harms consumers because trade barriers reduce foreign competition and increase prices.
Trade barriers → foreign competition ↓ → import prices ↑ → domestic prices potentially ↑ → consumer surplus ↓ → purchasing power ↓ → living standards ↓
Consumers may also experience less choice and potentially lower quality because domestic firms face less competitive pressure.
Domestic Producers
Domestic producers generally benefit because they face less foreign competition.
Imports ↓ → demand for domestic substitutes ↑ → domestic output ↑ → producer surplus/profits ↑ → employment potentially ↑
Protectionism can also harm domestic firms that rely on imported raw materials e.g UK firms, as tariffs increase their costs of production.
Government
Tariffs generate additional government revenue. Higher domestic profits and employment may also increase corporation and income tax receipts.
However, subsidies require government spending and therefore have an opportunity cost, potentially increasing the budget deficit.
Living Standards
Protectionism can protect jobs and wages in domestic industries, potentially raising living standards for workers in those sectors.
However, tariffs can increase the price of imported consumer goods and inputs.
Tariffs → imported goods/inputs become more expensive → cost of living + firms’ costs ↑ → inflationary pressure ↑ → real purchasing power ↓
Protectionism can also prevent countries from fully exploiting their comparative advantage, reducing specialisation and the gains from trade.
Equality
Protectionism may reduce inequality if it protects lower income workers who would otherwise lose manufacturing jobs because of foreign competition.
However, tariffs can be regressive. If tariffs increase the price of necessities, lower 9income households are affected more because necessities account for a larger proportion of their income.
Active recall
Revise with flashcards
Teacher Information

Specification 4.1.6
Past paper questions on this topic
6 matched questions to practise alongside these notes.
- A-level Paper 3, June 2025, Q1(e) · 25 marks
Evaluate the microeconomic and macroeconomic effects of a regional trade agreement between the UK and the EU.
- A-level Paper 2, June 2024, Q5(a) · 4 marks
Explain the likely impact of this tariff on the steel market in the US.
- A-level Paper 2, June 2022, Q7 · 25 marks
Evaluate the likely impact of an increase in protectionism on the global economy.
- A-level Paper 2, November 2021, Q6(d) · 12 marks
Discuss the likely impact on Rwandan consumers and clothing manufacturers of the increase in the tariff on imports of second-hand clothes. Use an appropriate diagram to support your answer.
- A-level Paper 2, November 2020, Q6(d) · 10 marks
Nigeria is considering joining the African Continental Free Trade Agreement. Assess policies the Nigerian government could use in response to the concerns of the country’s ‘manufacturers and trade unions’ (Extract B paragraph 3) if they join this trading bloc.