Government intervention

Written by: Umar Bostan
Updated on30 October 2026
Government Intervention
Governments intervene in markets to promote competition, prevent the abuse of market power and protect consumers, suppliers and employees.
Government Intervention to Control Mergers
The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) is the UK’s main competition regulator. Its role is to promote competition and prevent firms gaining excessive market power that could harm consumers through higher prices, reduced choice or lower quality.
One way of controlling monopoly power is therefore to prevent it developing in the first place.
Merger Control
The CMA monitors mergers and takeovers that could significantly increase a firm’s market power. A key concern is whether a merger would result in a substantial lessening of competition (SLC).
The CMA pays particular attention to where a merger could create or strengthen a firm with significant market power, with 25% market share acting as an important benchmark.
Market concentration ↑ → competition ↓ → market power ↑ → prices potentially ↑ + choice/quality ↓ → consumer welfare ↓
The CMA can:
Approve the merger if there are no significant competition concerns
Block the merger if it is likely to substantially reduce competition
Approve with conditions, such as requiring the firm to sell assets to limit its market power
This allows potentially beneficial mergers to take place while limiting their anti-competitive effects.
For example The CMA blocked the Sainsbury’s and Asda merger because the combined entity would hold a 31.4% national grocery market share .
Government Intervention to Control Monopolies
Governments may regulate existing monopolies to prevent the abuse of monopoly power.
Without intervention, a profit-maximising monopoly may restrict output and charge higher prices, reducing consumer surplus and overall economic welfare.
Price Regulation
A regulator can impose a maximum price on a monopolist to prevent excessive prices.
Monopoly power → profit maximisation at MC = MR → output restricted + price ↑ → consumer surplus ↓ + allocative inefficiency
The regulator could set a maximum price at the allocatively efficient level where MC =AR
For example Ofgem Energy Price Cap , Ofgem sets a maximum price per unit of gas and electricity for over 20 million households.
Maximum price ↓ → price ↓ + output ↑ → consumer surplus ↑ → allocative efficiency ↑
For natural monopolies, regulators may use RPI − X price-cap regulation:
Maximum price increase = RPI − X
For example, if inflation (RPI) is 5% and X = 2%, the firm can increase its price by a maximum of 3%.
Price caps can also encourage firms to reduce costs:
Costs ↓ by more than X → profit ↑ → incentive to improve productive efficiency
For example Ofcom Telecoms RPI − X Regulation . Ofcom applied RPI − X price caps to BT’s Openreach network infrastructure, forcing broadband wholesale prices to fall by up to 10% in real terms annually .
Profit Regulation
Regulators may directly limit the supernormal profit a monopoly is allowed to earn.
Profit regulation → supernormal profit restricted → exploitation of consumers ↓
Quality Standards
Monopolies face limited competitive pressure and may increase profits by reducing the quality of their goods or services.
Regulators can therefore impose minimum quality standards that firms must meet.
Quality standards → ability to cut quality ↓ → consumer protection ↑ → service quality maintained
For example Ofcom sets a legal quality standard requiring 93% of First Class mail to arrive within one working day, fining Royal Mail £5.6 million when performance dropped .
Performance Targets
Regulators can set measurable performance targets to improve the quality and reliability of services.
For example,NHS Target for 95% of emergency department patients to be seen within 4 hours .
Government Intervention to Promote Competition and Contestability
Governments can increase competition by reducing barriers to entry and encouraging new firms to enter markets.
Greater contestability → threat of entry ↑ → competitive pressure on incumbent firms ↑ → prices ↓ + efficiency/quality ↑
Promotion of Small Businesses
Governments can support small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) through:
Tax incentives and subsidies
Improved access to finance
Reduced regulation and red tape
Support for SMEs ↑ → barriers to entry ↓ → new entrants ↑ → competition ↑ → market power of incumbent firms ↓
For example, the UK's Start Up Loans scheme lent by over £1 billion to more than 100,000 SMEs that were rejected by high street banks.
Deregulation
Deregulation involves reducing or removing government rules and restrictions within an industry.
Deregulation → barriers to entry ↓ → contestability ↑ → threat of entry ↑ → incumbent firms forced to become more competitive
For example, removing Royal Mail’s legal monopoly enabled challenger firms (like DPD and Evri) to enter, capturing over 40% of the UK parcel market.
Competitive Tendering
Competitive tendering occurs when private firms compete to win contracts to provide goods or services on behalf of the government.
Competitive tendering → firms compete for contract → incentive to reduce costs + improve quality → productive efficiency ↑ → government expenditure potentially ↓
For example the NHS uses competitive tendering to push down prices for services such as cleaning and catering .
Privatisation
Privatisation is the transfer of assets or firms from the public sector to the private sector.
Private firms face a greater profit incentive and potentially greater competitive pressure.
Privatisation → profit incentive ↑ + competition potentially ↑ → incentive to cut costs ↑ → productive efficiency ↑
Competition may also encourage firms to better respond to consumer preferences, potentially increasing allocative efficiency and quality while reducing prices.
For example, BT was privatised in 1984.
Advantages:
Profit motive → stronger incentive to cut costs → productive efficiency ↑
Greater competition → prices ↓ + quality ↑
Greater incentive to innovate → dynamic efficiency ↑
Sale of state-owned firms → one-off government revenue ↑ . For example The UK Treasury raised £1.98 billion in a single year from selling off state shares in the postal service.
Disadvantages:
Privatisation may simply create a private monopoly → market power remains → prices ↑ + output ↓
Profit maximisation may come at the expense of service quality or social welfare
Cost-cutting may involve job losses or lower wages
Government loses future profits from the firm after receiving only a one-off payment from its sale
Government Intervention to Protect Suppliers and Employees
Governments may intervene where firms possess monopsony power, allowing dominant buyers to exploit suppliers or workers.
Protecting Suppliers from Monopsony Power
A monopsony is a market where a buyer has significant buying power.
Monopsony power ↑ → buyer able to negotiate lower prices from suppliers → supplier revenue/profit ↓ → potential exploitation
Governments can protect suppliers through:
Regulators monitoring buying practices . For example The UK GCA regulates top supermarkets penalising non compliance with fines up to 1% of turnover.
Minimum prices that buyers must pay . E.G Supermarket Minimum Milk Price Cap .
Protecting Employees
Firms with monopsony power in labour markets may be able to pay workers below the competitive equilibrium wage.
Governments can protect workers through:
National Minimum Wage legislation For example in 2024 set at £11.44/hr .
Rules on working hours and employment conditions For example 48 hour working week
Nationalisation
Nationalisation is the transfer of a privately owned firm or industry into public sector ownership, giving the government control over its operation.
A major argument for nationalisation is that the firm’s objective can shift away from profit maximisation towards social welfare.
Private monopoly → profit maximises at MC = MR → higher P + lower Q
Nationalised firm → greater focus on social welfare → output moves towards MC = AR → price ↓ + output ↑ → allocative efficiency ↑
On a monopoly diagram, the private profit maximising firm operates at Qmax, Pmax, where MC = MR. A nationalised firm may instead operate at Qallo, Pallo, where AR = MC and allocative efficiency is achieved.
On a natural monopoly diagram, the private profit maximising firm operates at Qmax, Pmax, where MC = MR. A nationalised firm may instead operate at Qallo, Pallo, where AR = MC and allocative efficiency is achieved. This will therefore mean the nationalised firm is operating at a loss thus to prevent shutting down it will require a subsidy per unit of A-B .
For example the nationalisation of British Rail in 1948 .
Advantages of Nationalisation
Social welfare prioritised over profit → government can increase output from Qmax to Qallo → price falls from Pmax to Pallo → consumer surplus ↑
At Qallo, AR = MC → allocative efficiency achieved → deadweight welfare loss eliminated
Essential services can be maintained even where they are not profitable → accessibility ↑ . E.G NHS
Natural monopolies remain as a single provider → avoids wasteful duplication of infrastructure E.G Network rail preventing parallel railway tracks .
Government can account for positive externalities, e.g. greater public transport provision → congestion + pollution ↓
Disadvantages of Nationalisation
At Qallo, the diagram shows AC > AR → firm makes a loss → Burden on govt finances
Government may therefore need to provide a subsidy equal to the gap between AC and AR → government spending ↑ → opportunity cost ↑
Weaker profit motive → incentive to minimise costs ↓ → X-inefficiency ↑ + productive efficiency ↓ E.G BT pre 1984 (Pre-privatization )
Less competitive pressure and lower supernormal profit → incentive to innovate/invest ↓ → dynamic efficiency may ↓
Active recall
Revise with flashcards
Teacher Information

More Revision Notes you might like
Specification 3.6.1
Past paper questions on this topic
9 matched questions to practise alongside these notes.
- A-level Paper 1, June 2024, Q6(d) · 12 marks
Discuss the likely concerns of the competition authorities regarding the proposed merger of the two companies referred to in Extract C.
- A-level Paper 1, June 2022, Q5(c) · 2 marks
Explain one likely concern the EU competition authorities may have had about the merger.
- A-level Paper 1, November 2020, Q6(c) · 10 marks
Assess whether complete nationalisation of the rail industry might protect employees.
- A-level Paper 1, June 2019, Q6(e) · 15 marks
Discuss methods of government intervention to protect consumers within the utilities markets, such as energy and telecommunications.
- A-level Paper 1, June 2019, Q8 · 25 marks
In October 2017 Scania, the Volkswagen-owned truck maker, was fined €880 million (£771 million) by the European Commission for colluding with five other truck manufacturers over a 14-year period. The firms had agreed to coordinate prices after experiencing additional costs of meeting emission regulations. With reference to an industry of your choice, evaluate why some firms engage in collusive behaviour.